How to Dress Like Jewish Comedian Sarah Sherman

Since Sarah's Fluevog clogs are out of stock, these multi-color heeled loafers will have to serve as a very fun dupe.

These suspenders made Sarah's list of things she cannot live without on The Strategist! "I always have them with me, because I like to wear big clown pants," she wrote. "I’ve never gotten anything tailored. Instead of buying clothes that fit, I just buy big clown clothes that don’t fit, so the suspenders come in handy."

Fashion Brand Company seems to be a go-to brand for Sarah, as she wears a lot of their pieces. She's even modeled for them! Sarah owns a FBC chessboard jacket in purple, but this scrap patchwork jacket will look just as good.

In an interview with Cultured Mag, Sarah shared that her starter pack includes a Killer Klowns from OuterSpace hat or a Texas Chainsaw Massacre hat. "I dont think I’ve left the house without one of them on for months," she explained.

An adherent of clown couture needs clown pants, no? Sarah has previously donned these bloomers (and the top below).

Complete the look with the clown top!

For the SNL50 Homecoming Concert, Sarah donned a Susan Alexandra necklace. It appeared to be custom-made with the bejeweled little creatures typically on Susan Alexandra keychains. So this glitter critter is a must.

While Sarah dressed for "Live with Kelly and Mark" in this top, it's certainly a good every day piece for your closet.

When she's not wearing a trucker hat, Sarah will sometimes do up her hair with clips and barrettes. These caterpillar clips feel very much her style.

According to a bit Sarah did on Weekend Update, her underwear consists of a diaper, a sports bra and a t-shirt she got in New Orleans that says "New Orleans." While this tee option isn't quite a novelty shirt, the letters do look like innards, which I think Sarah would appreciate.

Another item Sarah cannot live without, this is "her" smell. She says that it smells like balsamic vinegar and wet dirt and piss, and somehow still smells amazing.

Not only does this kooky top have pockets, it has an extra pocket. Surely that's why Sarah wore the blue, green and red version of it on TODAY.

A giant red, polka dot tie is necessity for anyone trying to emulate Sarah Sherman's looks.

Viola, a Texas Chainsaw Massacre hat — from the official store, no less!

The maximalist pattern and vintage-y feel of these pants are what make this garment so perfectly clown couture.

Another item in Sarah's starter pack is her giant scorpion keychain. She didn't specify a brand, so this one will do nicely.

On an episode of "Watch What Happens Live," Sarah wore a pair of puking clown earrings from Miss Anna Leigh Jewelry on Etsy. Since those are out of stock, the next best option are these puking burgers.

No piece of clothing has ever served circus in the way this dress does.

Sarah owns these pants in black, but I think she'd approve of this lime/chartreuse/vomit-colored pair.

With these hair clips, you can try attempt to recreate Sarah's paperclip hair clip look from her September 2025 appearance on "Late Night with Seth Meyers."

A rainbow sweater is essentially a basic in Sarah Sherman's world.

Though Sarah has a preference for Garbage Pail Kids, ephemera like Monchhichis seem very much up her alley.

These earrings toe the line perfectly between cute and creepy.

Yet another accessory Sarah cannot live without. She was put on to these glasses by the one and only Hannah Einbinder.

One more giant clown tie because why not?

These coppery, platform clogs lowkey give cockroach exoskeleton (complimentary, of course) and Sarah recently modeled them on Instagram!

Sarah famously wears her grandma's (of blessed memory) prosthetic eyeball as a necklace. While that's obviously a family heirloom, jeweler and artisan Rhys Kelly makes very cool eyeball jewelry to fill that gap in your wardrobe.